Arab Enabling Prevents Peace
Like most Israelis, I was glued to the TV listening to the speeches and watching the ceremony of the signing of declarations of peace between Israel and both the UAE and Bahrain. Historic is an understatement. It brought me back to the day in March 1979 when Israel signed the Camp David Accords with Egypt, ending decades of hostility.
Since then, Israel making peace with its Arab neighbors has been more or less a once a generation occurrence. Indications are that one or more of as many as five other Arab countries may also be on the verge of making peace with Israel as well, making this more regular occurrence. If we add the four that now have peace with Israel, and project that there could be another 4-5, its realistic that in this generation we could see Israel at peace with a third or more of the 22 nations of the Arab League. That’s all the more significance given the state of dysfunction that so many of the rest of the states of the Arab world, failed states that have no short-term prospect for peace domestically, much less with Israel. Nevertheless, looking at the prospects for peace, it’s an optimistic way to go into this Holiday season, and something to pray to become a reality.
I have to admit that I was skeptical, wondering if gestures from our Arab neighbors were real. Not without good reason. I remember being glued to the TV watching the historical moment of Egyptian President Sadat arriving in Israel on a Saturday night in November 1977. I remember being worried that the door of the Egypt Air plane would open, and an army of terrorists would spring out, throwing grenades and spraying Israel’s leaders with gunfire.
This week, I was worried as well, not that the White House ceremony would be attacked, but that one of the Arab participants would use the opportunity to infect Prime Minister Netanyahu with a deadly chemical, Russian and North Korean style. Of course, we’re living in the midst of a pandemic, so how much worse could they do. But I worried about that all the same, as baseless as it is.
Skepticism is not unwarranted. It was this month, September 13, 1993, that Israel signed a purported peace deal with the PLO at another White House ceremony with similar pomp and hope then that we have today vis a vis the Emirates and Bahrain. The Oslo Accords were a bust because even though the PLO officially recognized Israel in an exchange of letters a few days earlier, it was clear immediately that the recognition of Israel and Oslo Accords were a Trojan Horse to fulfill the PLO’s true goal of destroying Israel. Indeed, 25 years and thousands of Israeli lives and casualties later, the PLO (Palestinian Authority) withdrew its recognition of Israel.
As the Arab world comes to realize that Israel is not an obstacle to peace but a cornerstone of it, hopefully, the agreements this week will be more sincere, long lived, and mutually beneficial, ushering true peace to the Middle East. And hopefully, the peace agreements this month will forever overshadow the fake peace that the PLO promised and either never intended to or could deliver a generation ago. Let us hope that September 2020 becomes the defining paradigm of relations between Israel and its neighbors, not September 1993, or September 2000 when the unscrupulous terrorist Arafat unleashed what’s now called the Second Intifada.
A lot will depend on how the “Palestinian street” responds. Indeed, it was noted that to “celebrate” the peace agreements this week, as it was happening, Palestinian Arab terrorists from Gaza fired dozens of rockets at southern Israel. Others burned Emirati and Bahraini flags, and made wild statements of them being traitors to the Palestinian Arabs. As of this writing, a new wave of terror attacks – bombings, stabbings, car rammings, and all the other “innovative” ways that Palestinian Arab terrorists use to harm, kill, and maim Israelis – has not broken out. Hopefully it won’t. Hopefully Israeli Jews and Palestinian Arabs will continue to interact civilly as is the unreported day to day reality: Palestinian Arabs working and shopping in Israeli businesses, and Israeli Jews frequenting Palestinian Arab businesses and artisans.
Hopefully, this week’s milestone will have Palestinian Arabs looking carefully and talking among themselves. With the Jewish High Holiday season of deep introspection and prayer upon us, it wouldn’t be a bad thing for them to learn from us a little bit. Other than realizing that their leaders have failed them, they should see this week’s peace agreements offer another model.
For the past 55 years, since the establishment of the PLO and “birth” of the Palestinian Arab nation when there was no distinct ethnic or national group known as Palestinian (except for the British term which referred to the Jewish population of the Land of Israel during their control of the land from 1917-1948), the Arab world bought into the narrative that Israel was illegitimate, a usurper of Arab land, and had no right to exist. For decades, they enabled this narrative, allowing today’s Palestinian Arabs to believe that they were victims, and had no responsibility for their own plight. By enabling the Palestinian Arabs this way, they pushed peace further away if not made it impossible.
Now, the Palestinian Arabs have another model; a model that sees living in harmony and to one another’s mutual benefit, without war or threats. It’s a model that shows Palestinian Arabs, who had no real national identity before 1964, that a conglomerate of desert emirates can unite, and build an ultra-prosperous country without any particular history. And that the country that these emirates would establish could thrive, and not have Israel as an impediment in doing so. If the Emirates can do it, there’s no reason that the Palestinian Arabs can’t. But they need to come to the table and leave behind war, terror, threats, and incitement.
The morning after the signing, I was listening to the radio while driving. Peace was not just a topic of conversation between the host and guests of the morning program, but even in the music. As I was listening to one song after another about peace, I wondered whether in the most liberal of the Arab countries stepping up to make peace they have any kind of culture to sing and pray for peace as we do? Do the Arab states with which we have been in direct wars have that? Are they weary of war as we are, or do they see “armed resistance” as the only option, still?
If the rest of the world in general wants to see Palestinian Arabs uplifted, they should look at the model from this week and stop enabling them with funding that fuel their fantasies. Maybe then, we’ll all have something to sing about and celebrate.
Israel in the News