Did Oxygen First Appear on Earth Gradually or Suddenly? Israeli Scientists Find the Answer

Did Oxygen First Appear on Earth Gradually or Suddenly? Israeli Scientists Find the Answer

Human beings take oxygen for granted – but it didn’t always exist on earth. When did the gas O2 first appear on our planet? Was it sudden or a gradual event? These questions have been debated for a long time by scientists. 

It is known that about 2.5 billion years ago, the earth experienced what was possibly the greatest change in its history – according to the geological record, molecular oxygen suddenly went from nonexistent to becoming freely available everywhere. This phenomenon, which has been called the Great Oxygen Event (GOE), made possible the evolution of oxygen-using organisms to exist – and this included man. 

But was it indeed a “great event” in the sense that the change was radical and sudden, or were the organisms alive at the time already using free oxygen, just at lower levels? 

Scientists at the Weizmann Institute of Science in Rehovot who studied the enzyme evolution suggested that life figured out how to use oxygen long before the main event. They have now confirmed the hypothesis of scientists for years that oxygen appeared and persisted in the biosphere well before the GOE. They presented a completely new means of dating oxygen emergence – one that helps us understand how life as we know it now evolved.

Prof. Dan Tawfik of the institute’s biomolecular sciences department, whose team study the structure and function of proteins – especially enzymes – and how they evolve, has just published his proof in the prestigious journal Nature Ecology & Evolution. 

He noted that dating of the GOE is indisputable, as is the fact that the molecular oxygen was produced by photosynthetic microorganisms. Chemically speaking, energy taken from light split water into protons (hydrogen ions) and oxygen. The electrons produced in this process were used to form energy-storing compounds (sugars) and the oxygen – a by-product – was initially released into the surroundings. 

The question that has not been resolved, however, is: Did the production of oxygen coincide with the GOE or did living organisms have access to oxygen even before that event? One side of this debate claims that molecular oxygen would not have been available before the GOE, as the chemistry of the atmosphere and oceans prior to that time would have ensured that any oxygen released by photosynthesis would have immediately reacted chemically. 

A second side of the argument, however, suggests that some of the oxygen produced by the photosynthetic microorganisms may have remained free long enough for non-photosynthetic organisms to snap it up for their own use even before the GOE. Several conjectures in between these two have proposed “oases” or short-lived “waves” of atmospheric oxygenation. 

Research student Jagoda Jabłońska in Tawfik’s group thought that the group’s focus – protein evolution – could help resolve the issue. Using methods to trace how and when various proteins have evolved, she and Tawfik thought they could discover when living organisms began to process oxygen. Such phylogenetic trees are widely used to unravel the history of species – of human families and protein families. Jabłońska decided to use a similar approach to unearth the evolution of oxygen-based enzymes. 

To launch the study, Jabłońska sorted through around 130 known families of enzymes that either produce or use oxygen in bacteria and archaea – single-celled organisms that would have been around in the Archean Eon (the period between the emergence of life, about four billion years ago and the GOE). 

From these, she selected around half, in which oxygen-using or -emitting activity was found in most or all of the family members and seemed to be the founding function. That is, the very first family member would have emerged as an oxygen enzyme. From these, she selected 36 whose evolutionary history could be traced conclusively. 

“Of course, it was far from simple,” admitted Tawfik. “Genes can be lost in some organisms, giving the impression they evolved later in members in which they held on. And microorganisms share genes horizontally, messing up the phylogenetic trees and leading to an overestimation of the enzyme’s age. We had to correct especially for the latter.” 

The phylogenetic trees the researchers ultimately obtained showed a burst of oxygen-based enzyme evolution about three billion years ago – something like 500 million years before the GOE. Examining this time frame further, the scientists found that rather than coinciding with the takeover of atmospheric oxygen, this burst dated to the time that bacteria left the oceans and began to colonize the land. A few oxygen-using enzymes could be traced back even farther. If oxygen use had coincided with the GOE, the enzymes that use it would have evolved later, so the findings supported the theory in which oxygen was already known to many life forms by the time the GOE took place. 

The scenario that Jabłońska and Tawfik proposed looks something like this: Oxygen is one of the most chemically reactive elements around. Like one end of a battery, it readily accepts electrons, thus providing extra metabolic power. That makes it extremely useful to many life forms, but also potentially damaging. So photosynthetic organisms as well as other organisms living in their vicinity had to quickly develop ways to efficiently dispose of oxygen. This would account for the emergence of oxygen-utilizing enzymes that would remove molecular oxygen from cells. One microorganism’s waste, however, is another’s potential source of life. Oxygen’s unique reactivity enabled organisms to break down and use “resilient” molecules such as aromatics and lipids, so enzymes that take up and use oxygen likely began evolving soon after. 

“This confirms the hypothesis that oxygen appeared and persisted in the biosphere well before the GOE. It took time to achieve the higher GOE level, but by then oxygen was widely known in the biosphere,” said Tawfik. “Our research presents a completely new means of dating oxygen emergence, and one that helps us understand how life as we know it now evolved,” Jabłońska concluded.